His Twisted Choice Read online

  His Twisted Choice

  The Twisted Mosaic

  Book 3

  Amelia James

  Other Books by Amelia James

  Her Twisted Pleasures (The Twisted Mosaic - Book 1)

  One Wild Night - A Short Story

  Secret Storm

  Tell Me You Want Me

  The Devil Made Me Do It

  Their Twisted Love (The Twisted Mosaic - Book 2)

  www.TrashysTreasures.com

  Dedication

  To my chosen daughter, for teaching me that love has no limits.

  Table of Contents

  Dedication

  One Question

  Crooked

  What If?

  Something to Think About

  Normal is Boring

  Procedure's Bitch

  No Limits

  Naked

  The Invitation

  Show and Don't Tell

  Perfect

  Their Twisted Mess

  The Puzzle

  The Final Round

  His twisted Choice

  Snapshot

  A Note from the Author

  Acknowledgements

  About the Author

  One Question

  Fucking strange pussy at every opportunity seemed like the best way to forget about Talia, but even with two beautiful women competing for my attention, meaningless sex failed to charm my trouser snake like it used to. Even so, I’d be a fool to go home alone tonight. The last time I’d fucked two women I got to sit back and watch them go at it after they wore me out. Seeing two gorgeous, naked girls crawl all over each other was more fun than having them do it to me. I’d have been perfectly happy to let them carry on without me, as long as I was a spectator.

  Talia once told me we all have our kinks. Watching my woman fuck someone else had been my favorite perversion all the way back to… puberty. Hell, I’d probably been born with that bent. Maybe she knew that. Maybe she’d cheated on me so easily because somehow she knew my dick would be hard as a rock if I caught her. But when I caught her, it wasn’t seeing her naked underneath my best friend that pissed me off. Something had happened between them while I wasn’t looking, something they’d kept from me—a dirty little secret that festered and spoiled the arrangement I’d fought so hard to control. It went bad, but I still wondered if we—all three of us—could’ve made it work if we’d played by our rules.

  Don’t be stupid, Will. Three only works in porn.

  “So what’s it going to be, honey? One or both?” Alison, the tall brunette, took off her sexy librarian glasses and shook her wavy hair loose.

  Kathy, the curvy redhead, giggled and blushed. Her gaze had landed on me the moment I’d walked into the trendy dance club. Not a place I’d usually frequent. The house music’s driving bass line and pretty people laughing over fashionable drinks screamed ‘fake.’ But Kathy’s natural beauty drew me in.

  She quickly glanced away and bit her lip, so I deliberately sat next to her and chatted up her friend—the one drumming her fingernails on the bar while she waited for my answer. I’ve always suspected the quiet ones enjoy the most twisted kinks. I’ve yet to be proven wrong.

  “Hmm….” I twirled a strand of Kathy’s hair around my finger. “What do you want, sugar?”

  She grinned and chewed that plump red lip as she glanced at her friend.

  Alison elbowed her. “Tell him.”

  “I want you.” Pink colored her cheeks as she confessed.

  “I know that.” I slid closer to her, pinning her sexy body between me and her friend. “What else?”

  Alison slid her hand over Kathy’s shoulder and shoved her spaghetti strap down her arm. I bared her other shoulder. Alison held her friend’s wrist as she tried to cover up, but in the process, they managed to squeeze those tempting mounds together.

  My dick stiffened, and I sucked in a breath. “I’d like to see more of you two wrestling like that… but with less clothing.”

  “I’m game,” said Alison. “Come on, Kath.”

  I curled my finger under the redhead’s chin and looked into her fiery green eyes. “We can do this without her if that’s more comfortable for you.”

  Alison huffed.

  “No,” said Kathy. “I want you both… to be with both of you. Tonight.” She linked her fingers with mine. “I’m not so good with words.”

  “Who needs words?” I shifted forward and kissed her warm, red lips. Any resistance she might have been struggling with vanished as her body melted into mine. I slid my arm around her and caressed Alison’s thigh while she nibbled the redhead’s neck.

  Kathy’s hand found my hard-on as Alison’s lips touched mine.

  Yeah, this’ll be hot.

  The bartender cleared her throat, and the three of us split apart.

  Alison opened her purse, but I paid for their drinks. “Thank you,” she said. “Where to?”

  The only woman I took to my bed was Talia. Even though we hardly ever made it to the bed, I reserved it for her. She owned it… and me. I didn’t want anyone else tearing up my sheets. My list of excuses not to go to my place was running through my head when Kathy spoke up.

  “I’ve got the king-sized bed.”

  I winked at her. “Why am I not surprised?”

  She giggled and curled into me. “I might have one or two surprises for you.”

  “Mmm… I can’t wait.” I escorted the ladies out the door and followed them to Kathy’s place.

  A short drive and a long walk up three floors led us to a sprawling apartment. Packed bookshelves lined each wall, and random paperbacks littered the furniture. No T.V. I glanced at a title on the coffee table: Tell Me You Want Me. The cover showed a couple kissing. Yep. Always the quiet ones.

  Kathy tossed her purse in a chair and strolled to the kitchen. “Would you like a drink?” She grabbed a bottle of Jack from the pantry.

  “Thank you, I’ll have– whoa!”

  Alison snatched my belt and dragged me down the hall toward the bedroom. “Don’t waste time with drinks.”

  “Hey, wait for me!” Kathy abandoned the bottle and scampered after us.

  The bold brunette had my shirt undone by the time Kathy joined us. Alison unbuckled my belt, and Kathy pulled my shirt off as she moved behind us.

  I twisted the brunette’s hair around my fist, and she clawed my bare chest as I yanked her head back. “You like it rough.”

  “Mm-hmm.” She bit my lip and shoved my jeans to the floor.

  I caressed Kathy’s cheek and kissed her trembling lips, pulling her onto my lap as we all sat on the bed. “You like it sweet.”

  “For now.” She pushed me down and kissed my neck, sinking her teeth in as I slipped my hand under her skirt.

  Alison stripped down to her lingerie while I made out with her friend, then she helped me unzip Kathy’s dress and slide it off. Kathy wore a pale blue bra and matching lace panties, and Alison had on a black satin bra and thong with stockings and garters.

  “Beautiful,” I whispered to each woman as we kissed and explored.

  Kathy’s plump breast popped free from her bra, and her hard nipple tickled my chest as she bent down and stroked my dick.

  “Mmm… that’s good.” Sparks shot through my stiffening cock as I reached behind her friend and unhooked her bra, then she leaned over and dragged her nipple on my lips. I sucked her tits and fondled her ass while I pulled her thong aside and fingered her wet slit.

  “Nice move,” Alison purred. She bumped against Kathy and smacked her ass. “Climb over to the other side of him.”

  Kathy spread her legs over my thighs and dropped down beside me, pinning my body between the two women. The brunette mashed her breasts against my back as I turned
and stripped blue lace away from lush curves. I caressed one of Kathy’s full breasts and Alison massaged the other, crawling over me to form a twisted mass of flesh and satin.

  We each sucked a nipple, teasing and nipping until Kathy squealed and squirmed. Alison slipped her fingers over the panting girl’s clit while I kissed her. She moaned and gasped into my mouth, biting my tongue and sucking my lip. She growled and arched, and I held her down when she came.

  “Mmm….” Kathy moaned into my mouth.

  “Like that?” I whispered on her lips.

  She nodded. “Let’s make her come.”

  “Good idea.” I rolled over the two of them, and we caught Alison between us.

  She gasped and dropped back on the bed while I pulled her thong down as far as the garters allowed. I slipped a finger between her wet lips while Kathy unhooked her friend’s stockings but left them on as she tugged the thong off.

  Alison spread her legs and I knelt between them, flicking my tongue over her clit. She shuddered and moaned as I ate her delicious pussy. Her fingers tangled in my hair and my scalp stung as she thrashed under me. “Lick my cunt,” she groaned. Not too many women used that word. Talia loved it, and once we’d taught her to express her vulgar desires, she owned it. Probably said it to Alex all the time.

  Damn. Is she ever coming home?

  “Please.” A timid hand touched my shoulder. Alison’s hands were wrapped in my hair so that plea had to come from Kathy. Her eyes sparkled as she licked her lips. “Let me.”

  I sat back and watched as the redhead bent over her friend’s wet pussy and tasted it, licked her lips and tasted again. She looked up at me as if waiting for permission to continue.

  Is it her first time?

  Alison laughed deep in her throat. “Don’t stop now.”

  I moved behind Kathy and slid my hand between her legs as she leaned down again. “Tastes good, doesn’t she?”

  She nodded, her mouth filled with the other woman’s flesh.

  I watched and listened to the two women moan and sigh. My dick ached for attention so I stroked myself while finger-fucking Kathy. Her pussy tightened, turning hotter and wetter, but she was entirely focused on pussy licking so I eased my cock into her without asking. She gasped on her friend’s clit and the helpless woman cried out.

  Alex had cringed like that when I’d shoved my cock into Talia while she sucked his dick. Damn hot watching him fuck her mouth while I fucked her. Sharing her… the only thing better than watching her get laid.

  “Harder!” They both groaned at me.

  I pounded Kathy’s pussy, watching her ass bounce with every thrust. She tightened and came hard just as her friend exploded under her. I rescued my dick, saving what I had left for the sexy brunette.

  They pulled me down on the bed and lay on either side of me while we caught our breath.

  A wayward memory of the last threesome I’d gotten tangled in, the one that shattered my senses and ripped open my heart, haunted my thoughts. Damn it, why can’t I let that go? The women beside me stirred, dragging me back to reality, but as much as their naked presence tempted me, I preferred lingering with sordid images of my ex and her lover.

  I closed my eyes and plotted what to do next, but they made their move before I could come up with one.

  Alison’s tongue touched my balls while Kathy licked my shaft. I groaned and shuddered, allowing myself to indulge in a moment of hot greed. Then I leaned up on my elbows and watched as their tongues fought for contact with my dick, twisting around me, tangling with each other.

  They tongue-kissed with my cock between their mouths, and I had to slap my hand over my eyes to keep from coming. Blood boiled in my veins, building up a head of steam aching for release. The brunette swallowed my erection as deep as she could go, leaving her friend to tease my tight balls and quivering thighs.

  I grabbed Alison’s hair and pulled her up, kissing her open mouth as she crawled over my lips and settled on my face.

  Kathy mounted me and Alison turned around so they could kiss while I cock-fucked one and tongue-fucked the other.

  “You tasted so good.” Kathy said to her.

  “What tasted good? Say it.”

  “Your pussy.”

  “You know I hate that word. Say the other one.”

  Kathy sighed. “I liked licking your cunt.”

  Alison laughed. “I knew you would.”

  “He needs to fuck you.”

  “Yes, he does.”

  Kathy slid off me and Alison captured my dick. I fucked her, banging her hard while her friend watched, but I couldn’t ignore Kathy, so I flipped the brunette on her back and finger-fucked the redhead.

  “Ooo… I have a surprise for you.” Kathy got up and opened her nightstand. She pulled out a long, thick glass dildo with a twisted shaft and fat head.

  Always the quiet ones.

  She handed it to me, and I leaned over and kissed her.

  “This will come in handy.”

  Kathy spread her legs, and I eased the glass tool in slowly, letting her pussy adjust to it. Damn thing was bigger than any normal man, so I fucked her with a gentle stroke until she demanded more.

  Pleasure-pain shot though my body as Alison clawed my ass and dug her heels into my thighs, driving my cock in deep. I tightened my grip on both women as shuddering heat threatened to rip me apart. My body quaked, and I fucked them with a trembling rhythm.

  Alison came first, thrashing and swearing as she rode my fiery cock.

  A muffled moan carried through the pillow as Kathy clamped her hands over her breasts, pinching her nipples while I slammed the shiny dick in and out. She trapped my hand between her thighs, gasping as I shoved it in deep.

  Alison sat up and knocked me back. She and Kathy grabbed my dick and stroked me into oblivion, and I came in a shower of white hot bliss.

  “Fuck me.” I groaned and heard one of them giggle as I collapsed on the bed. When I opened my eyes, the two women were tangled up and kissing. Kathy had found another fake cock, a soft blue toy with a head at each end. Oh hell, I gotta watch this.

  They laughed and sighed as they drove that fake dick back and forth from one pussy to another. Sweet smiles and sparkling eyes highlighted their faces, and as they pleasured each other, I saw in them what I’d been missing.

  Joy.

  Hot sex? I got that by the truckload. Random fucking with no strings? No problem. Making a meaningful connection with a woman I cared about? Not since….

  Damn it. Do I really want another relationship? With Talia? I couldn’t imagine doing it without her. But maybe I needed to.

  A sweet sigh roused me from my moping. Alison had Kathy pinned to the bed, kissing her entire body, and she beckoned me to join them. I couldn’t refuse so I got on my knees, and we tickled the giddy redhead with our tongues until she couldn’t take any more.

  Right then I decided I loved focusing on one woman and spoiling her, even if I needed help to do it. That was why I’d let Alex into the bed I shared with Talia. I’d done it for her, even though we’d done it wrong.

  I left the women to their own devices and fished my cell phone out of my pocket to check the time. Late, but not so much that I couldn’t stay and watch as long as they allowed me to. I crossed my arms over my chest and stretched out to enjoy the show.

  ***

  My fingers tingled and a bright blue light pierced the peaceful darkness surrounding me. I’d fallen asleep with my phone in my hand, and the hardware vibrated against my palm, alerting me to a text message. The screen blinded me, so I dropped the phone face down on the nightstand while my eyes adjusted. I fumbled around for my pants, tripped over a shoe, and cursed as the spiky heel jabbed my foot.

  “Will?” Alison’s sultry, sleepy voice floated up from the bed.

  “Sorry.” I pulled my pants on and searched for my shirt.

  She turned the bedside lamp on, blinding me again.

  Kathy stirred beside her. “What’s going on?”


  I buttoned my shirt and apologized. “I got a message, so I figured I should get dressed.”

  “Trouble?” Kathy sat up and hugged her knees to her chest.

  “I’m a cop. Text messages in the middle of the night are never good news.” And with that thought in my head, I read the words on my screen.

  Talia: ‘I’m staying in Denver. For good. Please go to my apartment and turn off the water and AC until I can come back and pack up. Thank you for being there for me.’

  My legs gave out and I landed in the chair behind me. Staying… for good? What the fuck?

  “What happened?” Alison crawled across the bed and put her hand on my knee.

  Staying with Alex. Damn it! I’d promised to wait for her. We understood each other. Why the hell did she choose him?

  Kathy put her hands on my shoulders. “You’re shaking.”

  I shrugged her off and jammed my phone in my pocket. “A friend needs my help. I gotta go.” Damn right she needs help. She should’ve come to me, told me in person she wanted to move halfway across the country, so she could see the pain on my face when she ripped my heart out.

  I tripped over another shoe and kicked it into the wall. Alison ducked as it bounced back and flew over the bed.

  “I gotta get to her… talk some sense into her.” Or fuck it into her. Raw sex seemed to be the only language Talia could comprehend.

  “Ah….” Alison smiled. “A woman friend.”

  Kathy giggled.

  “What the hell is so funny?” I patted my pockets, searching for my keys as I scurried toward the living room.

  “We thought your friend was in trouble, but it appears you are.” Alison picked my keys up off the coffee table and dangled them in front of me. Kathy followed close behind, wrapping a pink silk robe around her, but Alison made no effort to cover her naked body.

  I snatched the keys and spun toward the door.

  “Good luck,” Kathy called after me.

  I stopped and turned. “I’m sorry for leaving like this.” I kissed each woman on the cheek. “Thank you for an enjoyable evening.”

  “I take it we won’t see you again.” Alison held my face in her hands.

  “No. Not if… if she has any doubt. I won’t be back.”